Nintendo’s Stock Takes a Tumble: A Right Royal Spoof of High Hopes and Harried Expectations

Ah, the stock market. A place where fortunes are made and lost, often with as much drama as a West End play, and just about as much sense. On Wednesday, the ever-esteemed Nintendo (NTDOY), that amiable titan of the gaming world, took a bit of a tumble. Not a fatal blow, mind you, but a rather embarrassing slip-imagine a chap tripping over his shoelaces at a garden party.

You see, Wedbush Securities, that august institution known for its remarkably astute analyses of all things tech, decided that it would be terribly clever to revise its rating on Nintendo’s U.S.-listed equity. From the dizzying heights of “outperform” (read: a rip-roaring endorsement) down to a far more pedestrian “neutral.” The result? Nintendo’s American depositary receipts (ADRs) slid by a sprightly 3%, while the S&P 500 index, that gentle giant, barely shuffled at a mere 0.1% dip.

Perhaps records are best left unbroken

Wedbush’s own Alicia Reese, a woman whose sharp eye can spot a tech trend from a mile away, seems to have found a fly in the ointment. She chopped her recommendation for Nintendo’s stock with the kind of deliberation one might expect from a judge handing down a sentence. Her target price of ¥14,000 (around $95.36, if you’re keeping score) is, shall we say, far less enthusiastic than her previous “buy” call.

And why, you ask, did Ms. Reese decide to make such a move? Well, my dear fellow, it was hardly due to a sudden attack of misgivings, but rather the result of what one might call “unrealistic expectations.” You see, the splendid new Switch 2 hybrid console had been released to such fanfare that it nearly caused a stampede at every shopfront, and Nintendo, bless its heart, struggled to keep up with demand in the early days (the console, released in June, was flying off shelves faster than one might order a round of gin at a country club).

However, and here’s where the plot thickens, Ms. Reese pointed out that the forecasts for Switch 2’s sales were, in her considered opinion, a tad on the high side. You see, dear reader, they were based on some rather inflated hopes that this new console could outstrip not only the original Switch, but also Nintendo’s older, venerable Wii. These were, as you might imagine, tall orders. In fact, to quote Ms. Reese, they were nothing less than “aspirational” figures, which is a lovely, charitable way of saying that expectations were outpacing reality.

Now, let’s not get too carried away with gloom and doom, for it’s hardly a matter of life and death. Nintendo’s machines, after all, are no slouches. The Switch 2 may not be charting the stars like its older siblings, but it is, to all appearances, still a very capable fellow, punching above its weight and amusing legions of gamers worldwide. But the notion that it could scale the lofty peaks achieved by the Wii or the original Switch is perhaps a mite too ambitious. As Ms. Reese so delicately put it, these are some “tough acts to follow.”

Switching off?

Let’s face it, folks-those two devices, the Switch and the Wii, have earned their place in history, with sales that make other consoles look rather modest, like a lightweight boxer taking on a heavyweight. Can Switch 2 live up to this? A fair question, and one that Ms. Reese feels the answer to is likely a resounding “no.”

And here’s the kicker: the Switch 2, for all its charms, is a decidedly pricier proposition than its predecessor. It comes with a rather hefty price tag, a 50% increase over the original model-enough to make even the most enthusiastic gamer pause and reconsider whether they truly need the latest gadget. Is it worth the extra coin? Well, the jury is still out on that one.

So, to sum up this little tale of market woe: Nintendo, the plucky underdog of the gaming world, finds itself in a bit of a pickle. Despite all the hoopla surrounding the Switch 2, the stock price has taken a knock, and expectations have been dialed down. But, as always, one never knows with this fickle market. A cheeky bit of code here, a sly marketing campaign there, and Nintendo could very well be back on top, laughing all the way to the bank. 🍀

2025-09-18 00:48

Perhaps records are best left unbroken

Switching off?

Read More