Dividend Hunters’ Masquerade: SCHD, VIG, and VYM’s Grotesque Dance

Alas, the realm of investment income is a masquerade ball where the true dancers hide behind gilded masks. Dividend stocks, those ostentatious nobles of finance, promise gold but often demand the patience of a saint and the ledger skills of a bureaucrat. Yet here, in this labyrinth of quarterly reports and yield percentages, one might find solace in the humble ETF-a basket of lesser-known peasants, perhaps, but peasants who know how to dance. Or so the tale goes. But not all baskets are created equal. Some are woven from golden threads; others, from the cobwebs of a neglected attic.

Consider the Schwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF (SCHD), a gentleman of moderate means but impeccable taste. With a trailing yield of 3.8%, it offers a meager but respectable dowry for those who seek stability. Its holdings-Chevron, AbbVie, Altria, and PepsiCo-are not kings, but they are the kind of neighbors who never miss a church service and always pay their rent on time. The fund’s index, that most peculiar Dow Jones U.S. Dividend 100, operates like a bureaucratic committee: it weights its members with the impartiality of a sleep-deprived clerk and ranks them by cash flow as though measuring the worth of a man by the number of boots he owns. And yet! This curious beast has grown by 45% in five years, 130% in ten, as if the very earth beneath it were infertile but the sky above had taken to raining gold coins.

Now, the Vanguard Dividend Appreciation ETF (VIG) is another creature entirely. A merchant of growth, it carries a satchel of stocks-Broadcom, Microsoft, JPMorgan-that have multiplied like rabbits in a warren. Its dividend yield, a modest 1.6%, is the price one pays for the privilege of dining at the table of the technocratic elite. The S&P U.S. Dividend Growers Index, its guiding star, is a fickle lover: it demands ten years of dividend increases but shuns the top 25% of yielders, as if fearing their generosity is but a mask for desperation. And yet! This ETF has soared 186% in a decade, its capital gains gleaming like the gilded spires of a cathedral built on the backs of cloud computing and artificial intelligence. A fine feast for those who do not need the crumbs but crave the crumbs’ possibility.

But let us not speak kindly of the Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF (VYM), that once-proud baron now reduced to a caricature of himself. Its yield, 2.5%, is a jest played by a jester who forgot the punchline. The FTSE High Dividend Yield Index, its ancestral estate, was once a beacon of prosperity, but since 2023, the fund’s price has swelled like a balloon filled with hot air-its constituents’ dividends unable to keep pace. Cap-weighting, that most insidious of market customs, has elevated the mighty while the meek are left to sip from the dregs. One might compare it to a banquet where the host serves everyone the same portion, but the guests with the largest appetites are given second helpings. A grotesque parody of fairness, and not a morsel worth swallowing.

And so, dear hunter of dividends, tread carefully. The market is a theater of illusions, and the truest wisdom lies not in the loudest proclamations but in the quiet calculation of risk and reward. SCHD and VIG may not be kings, but they know how to keep their crowns. VYM, however, is a court jester who has forgotten the script. Choose your dance partners wisely, lest you find yourself twirling in the dust with a pocket full of cobwebs. 🪙

2025-09-10 14:22

Read More