The Looming Specter of Tariffs and Stock Market Folly

by

There exists, in the sprawling metropolis of commerce we call the stock market, a peculiar sort of alchemy. A guild of sorts-let us call it The Order of Numbers Who Go Up[^1]-has long held sway over the collective imagination of investors. They chant incantations like “forward earnings” and wave wands labeled “CAPE ratios,” while their apprentices scurry about clutching scrolls inscribed with graphs that resemble nothing so much as the flight patterns of startled pigeons.

And yet, dear reader, there is trouble brewing in this once-thriving bazaar of dreams. When President Trump declared his grand “Liberation Day” tariffs earlier this year, the S&P 500 (^GSPC) plummeted by 10.5% in two days-a drop so precipitous it could only be described as falling faster than an alchemist’s lead balloon. Economists muttered dark prophecies of doom, warning that such measures might unravel the very fabric of economic reality itself.

But lo! As quickly as despair descended, hope sprang anew. The president paused the most draconian tariffs for 90 days, and companies began reporting profits robust enough to make even the greediest goblin blush. The index surged upward by 30%, proving once again that markets are less like rational machines and more like excitable puppies chasing shadows on sunny afternoons.

Alas, not all shadows bring joy. Recent revisions to the jobs data have cast a pall over the festivities. What was once hailed as economic resilience now appears to be little more than smoke and mirrors-or perhaps one of those clever illusions performed by wizards at the Unseen University of Coders[^2]. Businesses, wary of ever-shifting trade policies, have slowed hiring to a crawl. And when businesses hire fewer people, well, you don’t need a degree from the Guild of Alchemists and Venture Capitalists to know what happens next: consumers tighten their belts, sales stagnate, and eventually, the whole contraption grinds to a halt.

Jobs Growth Slows as Uncertainty Takes Root

Ah, the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), keeper of the sacred nonfarm payrolls report-a document revered across the land for its ability to distill the essence of employment into cold, hard numbers. Or at least, that’s how it used to work before politics got involved. In May and June, the BLS initially reported job gains totaling 286,000, but later revised them down to a paltry 33,000. Some claim these revisions were politically motivated[^3], though no evidence supports this assertion beyond the usual chorus of conspiracy theories sung by disgruntled citizens.

More troubling still, recent reports show the U.S. economy adding just 27,000 jobs per month between May and August-a figure lower than any period since 2010, barring the Great Recession or the brief interlude known as the Pandemic Era. This sluggish pace suggests that businesses, spooked by the capricious winds of trade policy, are reluctant to expand their ranks. And where business hesitates, prosperity falters.

Here lies the rub: While our esteemed leader proclaims the economy to be thriving thanks to his tariffs, the numbers whisper otherwise. For every boast of booming growth, there stands a line of unemployed workers waiting patiently-or perhaps impatiently-for something better to come along. And if history teaches us anything, it’s that economies built on sand tend to collapse when the tide rolls in.

Loading widget...

The Price of Hubris: Expensive Stocks and Fragile Foundations

Beyond the chaos wrought by tariffs, investors face another peril: valuations so lofty they seem almost otherworldly. The S&P 500 currently trades at 22.1 times forward earnings-a premium compared to historical averages[^4]. Such heights have been scaled only twice before: during the dot-com bubble and the pandemic-induced frenzy of 2020. Both times, gravity reasserted itself with predictable results.

Even more alarming is the cyclically adjusted price-to-earnings (CAPE) ratio, which now hovers at 37.9. To put this in perspective, consider that the five-year average sits at 33.4, and the ten-year average at 31.3. These figures suggest we are approaching levels unseen since the Roaring Twenties, when flappers danced and fortunes vanished overnight. One wonders whether modern investors will fare any better when the music stops.

Here, then, is the crux of the matter: caution is warranted. Wall Street analysts peer into their crystal balls and see little room for further gains in the months ahead. History tells us that bubbles burst, euphoria fades, and markets correct themselves-often violently. Something will break the spell of bullish sentiment sooner or later, and when it does, the fall may be steep indeed. So tread carefully, dear investor, lest you find yourself swept away by the tide of hubris and folly 🌊.

[^1]: The Order of Numbers Who Go Up is a fictional organization dedicated to perpetuating the belief that stock prices always rise in the long term. Members include hedge fund managers, financial advisors, and anyone who has ever uttered the phrase “buy low, sell high.”

[^2]: The Unseen University of Coders is a mythical institution where programmers and tech entrepreneurs gather to solve problems using algorithms, machine learning, and copious amounts of caffeine.

[^3]: Political interference in economic data is a topic of heated debate among scholars, pundits, and late-night talk show hosts. Whether true or not, it serves as a reminder that trust is fragile and easily broken.

[^4]: Historical averages are calculated using data from previous decades, during which time humanity managed to avoid both nuclear annihilation and widespread zombie outbreaks-a feat worth celebrating, surely.

Read More

2025-09-09 12:07