5 Things About ‘Supernatural’ That Made Zero Sense and 5 Things About It That Made Perfect Sense

The TV series ‘Supernatural’ offered an abundance of content during its extended run, covering everything from small-town ghostly encounters to vast interstellar conflicts. It carefully constructed a complex system of rules governing monsters, magic, and folklore, then continually expanded this system as the Winchester brothers encountered angels, seers, and ancient entities. This resulted in an expansive world for fans to explore, teeming with rich history and mythology to unravel.

As the series progressed, it offered instances that harmoniously followed its previous setup and instances that appeared to deviate or overlook the guidelines. Here are ten distinct aspects where the specifics are particularly noticeable, with five contradicting earlier details and five aligning with what the audience had learned from the show.

Zero Sense: Angel power levels

In simpler terms, initially, the angels are portrayed as extremely powerful entities capable of instant destruction with a single strike, easy movement through teleportation, and command over time. Castiel can clear entire rooms, higher-ranking angels can eliminate demons with just a touch, and an angel blade is depicted as the only thing that can match their power. However, as the series progresses, mid-level angels begin to struggle against demons that previously feared them, while common human strategies like traps neutralize beings who used to shrug off gunfire and spells.

The series demonstrates significant fluctuations in power associated with grace, lacking a consistent reference point. Castiel experiences periods of losing and regaining grace, with his abilities fluctuating more than initially seen. Archangels exhibit a mix of god-like powers and regular brawls, while magical barriers that once stood strong against any scrutiny crumble against similar threats. The series offers various demonstrations of angelic capabilities, but these examples do not establish a consistent and reliable scale.

Perfect Sense: Salt and iron

The toolset for warding off ghosts and various spirits is rooted in popular folklore, which considers salt as a boundary and iron as an interference. Hunters often use rock salt pellets to disperse apparitions, draw lines of salt across entryways to prevent access, and carry iron items to counteract ghostly power. Burning remnants, personal belongings, or a cord finishes the task when folklore indicates a haunting’s origin point.

In various settings, both modern and historical, the series consistently employs a set of tools and techniques, demonstrating their effectiveness. For instance, ghosts connected to cursed objects are vulnerable to iron, salt lines can ward off spirits unless disturbed, and cleansing a tether decreases activity prior to a final purification. This recurring application of these methods provides viewers with a reliable starting point that aligns with folklore and maintains consistency from one case to another.

Zero Sense: Hunter finances and IDs

Throughout the show, the Winchesters are always on the move, staying at motels, fueling their classic car, and carrying specialized equipment. However, their primary sources of income – which include credit card fraud, pool hustling, and false insurance claims – are seldom depicted as legal. The series shows them using various aliases under classic rock names to cycle through badges from federal and local agencies. They manage to pass routine checks that regular agents would encounter.

I’ve noticed that the series frequently depicts narrow escapes from law enforcement, yet lasting repercussions seldom follow. It’s fascinating to see how databases often fail to recognize repeated faces when presented with different names, and background checks yield immediate results even in critical situations. However, the show underscores the limitations of these tactics when applied across numerous jurisdictions due to the vast scale of travel and frequent shifts in identities.

Perfect Sense: Men of Letters bunker

In simpler terms, the bunker located in Lebanon, Kansas serves as a high-quality facility where the brothers carry out their research, storage, and security operations. It is equipped with various resources such as a library of ancient knowledge, a room filled with maps, isolation areas for containing unusual artifacts, and an armory stocked with unique tools not commonly found among field hunters. This space allows them to manage complex investigations effectively, safely catalog cursed items, and trace obscure rituals due to its extensive resources.

The spot where they are based also links the Winchesters to an inherited network of artifact repositories and case documentation. This past explains how they have access to rare weapons and why they can swiftly cross-reference various languages and magical systems. With the bunker involved, the series is able to explain their quick readiness, secure storage for hazardous goods, and defense against invaders with multiple protective measures.

Zero Sense: The Colt rules

In simpler terms, the show introduces the Colt as a unique firearm capable of eliminating most entities, except for certain ones that aren’t specifically listed. This weapon is effective against creatures that are impervious to regular ammunition and knives, but it proves ineffective against beings like Lucifer. The gun undergoes alterations with the assistance of demonic wisdom, but its limitations are not consistently explored or explained throughout subsequent seasons.

Instead of having a consistent set of rules, a viewer finds themselves witnessing varying results. In one instance, the gun eliminates formidable enemies, whereas in another, it’s hindered by a superior force. Later, the gun disappears again after briefly reappearing. The show fails to present a clear list of exemptions or a stable formula for bullet creation that remains easily accessible to the hunters, leading to unpredictability when dealing with the Colt.

Perfect Sense: Vessels and consent

Angels and archangels can only take over a human body if it’s a suitable match and they have explicit approval. The series makes clear that powerful angels demand robust hosts capable of enduring the stress, and consent is an inviolable rule that cannot be circumvented through brute force. The narrative suggests that some humans are special vessels for archangels, which explains why certain negotiations hold greater significance than a swift battle.

In the Winchester family saga, it’s hinted that divine intervention plays a significant role. A cupid, as per heaven’s command, unites John and Mary to conceive children destined to be exceptional hosts, which makes subsequent events seem deliberately orchestrated rather than chance-driven. The principle of consent remains crucial in shaping plot developments, with angels resorting to temporary vessels when a genuine one declines. The consequences are evident when compatibility is poor, shaping character choices over the course of the story.

Zero Sense: Wards and traps inconsistency

As a movie-goer enamored with the supernatural world on screen, I’ve come across some fascinating concepts like Devil’s traps and Enochian sigils – tools that have the uncanny ability to bind or repel various entities. Whether it’s the floor beneath our feet, the ceiling overhead, or even intricate tattoos adorning a character’s skin, these symbols can bring demons and angels to an immediate halt. Interestingly, even a minor gap in the design is enough to set a target free. However, as the plot unfolds in different episodes, I’ve noticed that some creatures that initially showed no resistance to these symbols, have seemingly found a way around them. In other instances, the designs, when depicted as fully warded, have failed without any visible breach, adding an intriguing layer of mystery to these supernatural stories.

The thickness and design of salt lines and symbol markings can be unpredictable, without any obvious cause. In some instances, a single salt ring may effectively hold back a potent spirit, while in others, a stronger line seems to offer little resistance to a mere energy spark. The series frequently depicts the creation of these symbols and explains their drawing process, yet the outcome doesn’t always correspond with the precision demonstrated on screen, leaving one questioning the reliability of these protective measures when an urgent exit or shocking event occurs in the storyline.

Perfect Sense: The Impala setup

The 1967 Chevy Impala serves as a portable shelter stocked with weapons, lock picks, and emergency essentials for the brothers. The trunk houses shotguns, iron bars, sharp silver blades, and hex bags, enabling them to confront various creatures without needing to revisit a fixed armory. The vehicle is equipped with EMF meters and salt rounds, and it transports personal items that make it a moving home.

When it’s necessary to adopt a lower profile, license plates are switched, and maintaining the car becomes part of the daily routine for these detectives during their downtime between cases. An entire episode seen through the Impala’s eyes showcases its role in surveillance, relaxation, and swift departures. The vehicle also illustrates how it enables two individuals to live on the move while carrying a versatile arsenal suitable for various dangers.

Zero Sense: Death not sticking

The narrative consistently features key characters undergoing repeated deaths and resurrections, which can make it unclear what’s at stake from the start. For instance, Dean is sent to Hell then brought back, Sam perishes only to come back with consequences, while Castiel experiences multiple destructions followed by reappearances. Moreover, even celestial beings like Death and the Reapers undergo changes in roles and office over the course of the show.

The afterlife is extensively described as consisting of Heavens, Hells, and nothingness, but the conditions for permanent departures can change when fresh agreements or loopholes in the universe arise. Dealing with demons at crossroads, removing souls, and cosmic restarts sometimes make partings turn into diversions. The series explains how one can come back each time, but the increasing number of exceptions makes it challenging to view death as a definitive end.

Perfect Sense: Mark of Cain lore

The Mark of Cain binds its bearer to the First Blade, empowering them but at a steadily increasing price. When marked, the individual endures wounds that would typically be fatal for an ordinary hunter and obtains the capacity to neutralize ancient dangers. However, this also triggers a dangerous propensity towards unrestrained violence that is difficult to manage. The First Blade remains inactive without the Mark, thus preventing it from being used carelessly during common skirmishes.

By getting rid of the Mark, the Darkness is unleashed, which raises the question of why nobody removed it earlier. This outcome links current decisions to the oldest family tragedy in the lore and ties individual stories to an ancient jail. The Mark also reveals why a common sword strikes harder than complex magic when the proper connection is made, and why the brothers must consider power against the harm it brings.

The removal of the Mark releases a Darkness that was previously hidden, leading one to wonder why it wasn’t erased before. This action links present-day actions to an ancient family tragedy in the lore and connects personal stories to an old prison. The Mark also shows why a regular sword can be more effective than magical powers when they are linked together, and why the brothers must think about the benefits and drawbacks of power.

Share your favorite sense or nonsense moments from ‘Supernatural’ in the comments.

2025-09-04 18:47