5 Things About ‘The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring’ That Made Zero Sense and 5 Things That Made Perfect Sense

by

The incredible voyage depicted in ‘The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring‘ (2001) spellbound viewers with its stunning vistas and compelling narration. Under the guidance of director Peter Jackson, this cinematic interpretation of J.R.R. Tolkien’s renowned novel breathed life into Middle-earth, seamlessly combining adventure, emotion, and peril in a manner that captivated countless individuals.

To put it simply, the movie wasn’t flawless; there were instances where I found myself bewildered by certain decisions, while other times, I was left in awe by pure brilliance. In the following analysis, I’ll delve into five aspects that left me perplexed and five that shone brilliantly, switching between the two to understand what made this film both enigmatic and indelible.

Made Zero Sense: Gandalf’s Inconsistent Power

Gandalf the Grey, portrayed by Ian McKellen, is a formidable sorcerer whose powers appear to vary based on different situations. In Moria, he courageously wards off a fearsome Balrog, a creature of fire and darkness, using astonishing magic. Conversely, earlier in the Shire, he finds it challenging to persuade Bilbo to let go of the One Ring, resorting to stern words rather than casting any spells.

I find it bothersome that there’s an inconsistency in Gandalf’s abilities. Why can’t he utilize a fraction of his power to help Bilbo or shield the Fellowship from lesser dangers instead of only showing his full strength during dramatic moments? It seems as though the film manipulates his power level for added effect, leaving us uncertain about his true capabilities.

Made Perfect Sense: The Shire’s Warmth and Simplicity

The initial scenes of the Shire demonstrate exceptional skill in creating a vivid, immersive world. From the verdant rolling hills to the snug, homely hobbit homes, every aspect exudes warmth and camaraderie. The hobbits’ affection for food, music, and tranquility effectively establishes their down-to-earth personalities.

Leaving Frodo’s foundation behind made his departure even more heart-wrenching. I found it hard to part from such a flawless home, and it adds depth to the significance of his journey. The Shire’s enchantment is not by chance—it embodies Tolkien’s affection, and Jackson captures it brilliantly.

Made Zero Sense: The Ringwraiths’ Sudden Weakness

The fearsome minions of Sauron, known as the Nazgûl, tirelessly pursue the One Ring, leaving no stone unturned in their pursuit – even going so far as to stab beds and chase hobbits across open fields. However, at the Ford of Bruinen, they are swept away like leaves in a storm by a powerful river, with Arwen’s magic playing a part, but it seems somewhat improbable that these seemingly invincible entities could be defeated so effortlessly.

It’s quite surprising how easily they seem to be defeated by water. One might wonder if they purposefully put themselves in harm’s way near rivers or simply lack a contingency plan when dealing with such elements. Although the visual is striking, it somewhat undermines their ominous presence, making them appear less formidable and more vulnerable.

Made Perfect Sense: Frodo’s Reluctant Heroism

Frodo Baggins, played by Elijah Wood, doesn’t fit the typical hero mold, but that’s what makes him shine. He is diminutive, anxious, and weighed down by the Ring’s corrupting influence, yet he bravely accepts the task of delivering it to Mordor. His quiet bravery has a gritty, authentic feel, unlike the overused trope of the predestined chosen one.

I admire the way the movie portrays Frodo’s struggle with hesitation during the Council of Elrond, where he bravely offers to take on the task despite his fear. This scene encapsulates the essence of the story – ordinary individuals confronting extraordinary obstacles. Frodo’s journey resonates strongly and embodies a distinctly human experience.

Made Zero Sense: The Council of Elrond’s Chaos

At the Council of Elrond, where the destinies of the Ring are being deliberated, there seems to be an unruly chaos. Elves, dwarves, and men argue fiercely, bordering on physical confrontations, over who should bear the responsibility of the Ring. Despite its dramatic nature, it is puzzling to see these wise leaders behaving imprudently when the fate of the world hangs in the balance.

It seems like there’s a sense of escalation required, but the portrayal appears excessive. A more nuanced discussion with persuasive points could’ve underscored their wisdom and emphasized the Ring’s contentious influence without resorting to loud arguments. Instead, it just turns into a chaotic exchange until Frodo finally intervenes.

Made Perfect Sense: The Ring’s Corrupting Influence

The One Ring isn’t merely an ornament; it has a life of its own in the story. The film masterfully portrays its enticing allure, from Bilbo’s struggle to hold onto it to Boromir’s increasing fixation on it. Every time we see the Ring, you can feel the weight of temptation hanging over it.

This functions effectively due to its understated yet relentless nature. I could sense the effort etched on Frodo’s face as the Ring took its toll, and it transformed Sauron’s danger into a tangible, personal threat instead of a distant evil. The Ring’s influence masterfully builds the story’s suspense.

Made Zero Sense: Aragorn’s Reluctance to Lead

In the movie, Viggo Mortensen’s character, Aragorn, is the rightful king of Gondor, but throughout the film, he avoids embracing his royal destiny. Despite being an accomplished warrior and a born leader, Aragorn is deeply troubled by Isildur’s inability to destroy the Ring long ago. It seems strange that he is so immobilized due to another’s past error.

As a movie buff, I find it somewhat contrived that they’re making him appear more brooding. A man with his level of experience should exude more self-assurance, or at least have a convincing rationale for his uncertainty. The film seems to overemphasize this angst without fully fleshing out its origins.

Made Perfect Sense: The Fellowship’s Diversity

The Fellowship is truly ingenious, featuring hobbits, a wizard, an elf, a dwarf, and two men. Each member possesses distinct abilities and weaknesses, making for a harmonious yet entertaining group. For instance, Legolas’ archery skills contrast beautifully with Gimli’s unyielding determination.

The movie effectively portrays character conflicts akin to the initial animosity between Legolas and Gimli, which later evolves into a strong friendship. This dynamic resonates with genuine relationships, making their eventual separation all the more poignant.

Made Zero Sense: Galadriel’s Temptation Scene

When Frodo presents Galadriel with the Ring, her abrupt change into a dark, power-craving version of herself catches one off guard. Cate Blanchett’s portrayal is powerful, yet the transformation seems excessive and misplaced. It’s puzzling to imagine how an ancient, wise elf like Galadrile could contemplate accepting such a Ring.

The scene aims to depict the alluring power of the Ring, but it comes off as overly dramatic. A subtler, more internally conflicted Galadriel might have been more impactful, given her character’s supposed strength and nobility. It’s an unusual flaw in the portrayal of this character.

Made Perfect Sense: The Balrog Confrontation

The scene at Moria, particularly Gandalf’s confrontation with the colossal, fire-breathing Balrog, is simply awe-inspiring. This titanic beast seems like a formidable natural element, and Gandalf’s selfless act to shield the Fellowship is profoundly moving. The moment when the bridge of Khazad-dûm crumbles beneath their struggle is undeniably iconic.

What makes it effective is its gradual escalation. The mines have an air of oppression, the orcs’ drums resonate with dread, and when the Balrog emerges, it’s a climactic moment that seems justified. I was on tenterhooks, and it’s a scene that encapsulates the film’s high-stakes tension.

Read More

2025-07-28 16:47