Warren Buffett’s American Express: A Tale of Prosperity and Caution

Within the great expanse of Berkshire Hathaway‘s public equities, the glimmer of familiar giants like Apple and Coca-Cola often captures the limelight. Yet, for the discerning observer, there exists a subtle player at the pinnacle of this financial hierarchy, demanding our attention.

This titan, American Express (AXP), commands a formidable 21.6% stake held by the oracle himself, Warren Buffett. Having surged an astounding 217% over the past five years—as of July 23—it stands as a paragon of resilience in turbulent times.

But in our quest for understanding, we must ponder whether this is a moment that beckons investment or a siren’s call fraught with peril.

In the Arena of Credit

The esteemed company in which Berkshire holds such an esteemed position, American Express, possesses traits akin to a well-forged sword—its edges sharp, ready to cut through the competitive din of the financial landscape. At the heart of its business lies a moat, not of water but of formidable prestige and recognition, a quality highly valued by Mr. Buffett, one who sees beyond mere numbers into the very soul of a corporation.

Here lies the essence of the American Express brand, a crown jewel in the marketplace, whispered about with reverence by households of affluence. Its offerings are not merely cards; they are talismans of status. The allure of remarkable rewards, coupled with the burdensome annual fees, attracts an elite clientele seeking not just utility but also the esteem of belonging.

Moreover, the company thrives under the bounteous sun of network effects—a cycle of mutual reinforcement that enriches both the merchant and the cardholder. As merchants embrace the card, their clientele flourishes, and in turn, cardholders feel empowered by expanded opportunities—a delicate dance of reciprocity that speaks to the heart of economic interdependence.

The steadfast performance of American Express becomes more pronounced amidst the cacophony of economic uncertainty. While external forces may induce tremors—a fearsome tarantella of tariffs—a resolute calm pervades the financial behemoth. In its latest quarter, it revealed a commendable 9% increase in revenue, driven by a 7% rise in consumer spending.

Despite the ominous shadows of recession looming large over the horizon, American Express continues to instill confidence in its investors. A striking indicator: the proportion of overdue card member loans remains markedly lower than the industry average, while the company’s net write-off rates displayed a commendable decline.

This bastion of profitability stands as a testament to its wisdom, for it generated a net income of $2.9 billion in the second quarter. The stewardship of excess cash is demonstrably prudent, with share buybacks and dividend payouts reflecting a commitment to enhancing shareholder value—a bouquet of investor-friendly practices in the ever-shifting garden of finance.

A Cautionary Path

Alas, all that glitters is not gold, and the stellar performance of Amex in recent years shrouds a disquieting reality—today’s stock is clothed in the fine fabric of high valuation. The market, in its ineffable wisdom—or perhaps folly—demands a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 21.5 to partake in the ownership of this illustrious stock. This number, while not an outright insult to reason, invokes a measure of caution, whispering tales of overvaluation as it soars above its trailing three-year multiple.

For the intrepid investor, the allure of well-established companies such as American Express must land on the watch list, indeed. The forecast remains bright, with the potential for consistent revenue and earnings growth further illuminated by the power of brand loyalty and embedded network effects. Yet, as in the theater of life, the unfolding drama of valuation multiples remains inscrutable and shrouded in enigma.

The question lingers—what fortunes shall unfold in five or ten years? Could a mere shifting of the P/E ratio bring forth an unfavorable wind, or might it fan the flames of profound gain? American Express, in its current standing, evades the designation of a simple ‘no-brainer’ investment, for it remains a paradoxical marvel—both promising and perilous.

In our contemplative silence, let us not merely seek profit, but wrestle with the deeper questions of our investments: in what manner are we shaped by the very forces we endeavor to master? 🤔

2025-07-26 18:54

In the Arena of Credit

A Cautionary Path

Read More