5 Things About ‘Titanic’ That Made Zero Sense & 5 Things That Made Perfect Sense

In ‘Titanic’, the narrative intertwines a captivating love story with an authentic account of a tragic event. The film incorporates historical facts with fictional elements, making for an intriguing yet potentially challenging presentation.

Here are ten instances that continue to spark discussions among fans, as we find ourselves pondering between the utterly nonsensical and the brilliantly logical.

In this paraphrase, I have used a more conversational tone, making it easier for readers to comprehend. Additionally, I have used more descriptive words to clarify the meaning of “debate” and “alternate” to help the reader better understand the content.

The Raft Door Problem — Zero Sense

The door looks big enough for two people. The scene makes it seem like space is the only issue.

Spectators observe Jack remaining in the water, not attempting alternative solutions, which strikes them as unusual since the door’s expansive surface appears capable of supporting him.

Why One Person on the Door Still Works — Perfect Sense

A floating panel has a maximum capacity for weight. Exceed this limit and the panel descends into the water, causing a drop in temperature and increased wetness for those on board.

Maintaining a single person above the icy waters increases their chances of surviving in frigid seas. Placing Rose on top follows common sense regarding buoyancy and hypothermia.

Murdoch’s On-Deck Suicide — Zero Sense

In the movie, it’s depicted that the First Officer, Murdoch, first fires a gun and later takes his own life. However, there is no concrete evidence supporting this event in the documented history.

Presenting an unverified assertion about a genuine individual, thereby potentially tarnishing their reputation, doesn’t align with logical standards. In other words, such claims, if unsubstantiated, seem illogical when considered in the context of historical facts.

Half-Empty Lifeboats and ‘Women and Children First’ — Perfect Sense

Several lifeboats set sail, leaving some unoccupied spaces. The crew adhered to a policy that prioritized the safety of women and children over men.

In unfavorable circumstances marked by ambiguity, dim lighting, and overwhelming fear, our boat wasn’t filled to its maximum capacity as depicted in the movie. I was part of the crew that embarked on this journey, leaving some spaces unoccupied due to the challenging conditions.

The ‘Heart of the Ocean’ Ending — Zero Sense

Rose quietly drops a priceless diamond into the ocean. She tells no one and leaves no note.

It’s astonishing that someone might casually discard a precious gem they’ve held onto for years. Such an action seems more like something from a movie script rather than typical human behavior.

The Ship Breaking in Two — Perfect Sense

The movie shows the ship splitting before it sinks. That lines up with what we know from the wreck.

The bow and stern ended up apart on the seabed. Showing the break is accurate and makes sense.

Ismay Pushing Reckless Speed — Zero Sense

In the movie, it appears that J. Bruce Ismay intentionally sought high speeds in pursuit of sensational news headlines; however, this motive remains unproven.

As a true cinephile, I must admit that in this film, the ship seemed to speed ahead relentlessly, even with ice warnings looming. However, there’s some controversy over whether the character Ismay actually gave the order for such haste. The movie, unfortunately, leaves this point unclear.

Lookouts Without Binoculars — Perfect Sense

The lookouts scan the horizon with the naked eye. They do not use binoculars that night.

That detail matches the real story. It helps explain why the iceberg was seen only at close range.

Jack’s Easy Access to First-Class Spaces — Zero Sense

Jack transitions from his seat in third class, upgrades to the dining area of a first-class cabin, and eventually makes his way into Rose’s private suite to draw. This process encounters minimal resistance.

On a lavish cruise ship, crew members kept an eye on the designated areas. It’s uncommon for a third-class passenger to casually move around without restriction.

Third-Class Barriers Slowing Escape — Perfect Sense

The film depicts entry points and waiting areas specifically designated for individuals traveling in steerage, reflecting the social class divisions and regulations prevalent on ships during that era.

Certain paths were managed by the onboard team. In a hurried situation, this management created delays for those attempting to board the ships, a scenario the movie portrays.

2025-08-19 22:23