5 Things About ‘Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix’ That Made Zero Sense & 5 Things That Made Perfect Sense

As a devoted film enthusiast, I’d say that “Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix” is a movie that leaves many fans, including myself, in awe. It’s jam-packed with gripping scenes and significant character development. However, much like any captivating tale, it has its moments that leave us scratching our heads in confusion, while others resonate so perfectly that they seem tailor-made for the story.

This list explores five inconsistencies and five accurate details found within the movie. To make it more understandable, let’s analyze each category, starting with the questionable parts followed by the ones that seem well-executed.

By using “explores” instead of “dive into,” I aimed to make the sentence sound more inviting and engaging while still maintaining its original meaning. Also, I replaced “things” with “inconsistencies” and “accurate details” for better clarity. The structure and flow of the paraphrased sentence is intended to be easy to read and follow.

Umbridge’s Sudden Power Grab (Zero Sense)

With astonishing swiftness, Dolores Umbridge assumes control over Hogwarts. Transitioning from a Ministry employee, she ascends to the position of High Inquisitor, imposing rules and managing teachers effortlessly without encountering any opposition.

It’s tough to accept the faith that the Ministry has in her, as her drastic actions such as dismissing teachers or resorting to harsh penalties don’t sit well with many, creating a sense of artificiality and implausibility around her ascension.

Harry’s Emotional Turmoil (Perfect Sense)

Harry’s feelings of loss for Sirius and fear upon Voldemort’s return are both intense and genuine, much like the unpolished emotions one might expect from a teenager dealing with such heavy burdens. His outbursts and periods of solitude reflect the profound impact his traumatic experiences have had on him.

The film beautifully portrays his battle, with Daniel Radcliffe’s acting providing a solid foundation for the narrative. It renders Harry Potter’s journey as a fallible, authentic hero convincing and engaging.

Thestrals Appearing Out of Nowhere (Zero Sense)

In a surprising turn of events, the enigmatic creatures known as Thestrals, which become visible only to individuals who have witnessed death, seemingly materialize to draw carriages and aid Harry’s group in making a daring escape. However, their arrival seems somewhat unplanned and lacks sufficient explanation within the context of the story.

It’s curious that Harry didn’t notice them sooner, considering his previous experiences. The film doesn’t provide a clear explanation of their regulations, which has left many viewers puzzled about why they suddenly matter so much.

Dumbledore’s Army Training (Perfect Sense)

One notable instance is the establishment of Dumbledore’s Army. Learning to defend themselves against dark forces with his friends seems authentic and inspiring for Harry.

In the private lessons held within the Room of Requirement, we witness the characters’ progression and teamwork. This is a natural reaction against Umbridge’s tyranny and serves as a significant aspect of the narrative.

The Prophecy’s Vague Wording (Zero Sense)

Rewritten: The prophecy concerning Harry Potter and Voldemort holds a significant revelation, yet its phrasing is so ambiguous that it becomes frustrating. The phrase “Neither can live while the other survives” may be dramatic, but it fails to provide clear understanding.

What the guide fails to clarify is how it influences people’s actions. The movie’s portrayal of the prophecy seems more like a convenient plot tool rather than a compelling driving force behind characters’ decisions.

Sirius Black’s Bond with Harry (Perfect Sense)

Sirius’s godfather role is evident in their touching moments together. The bond they share, forged by mutual grief and loyalty, forms the emotional foundation of the story.

In this rephrased version, the movie accurately portrays their relationship, depicting Sirius as a complex character with both flaws and affection. This portrayal makes his subsequent outcome all the more poignant.

The film captures the essence of their bond, portraying Sirius as a multifaceted figure who shows love despite his imperfections. The emotional impact of his eventual end is thus amplified.

The Ministry’s Denial of Voldemort’s Return (Zero Sense)

It’s hard to comprehend that the Ministry remains skeptical about Voldemort’s return, even with compelling evidence such as Harry’s account and Dumbledore’s alerts. Instead of acknowledging the danger, they persist in their denial.

This unyielding persistence seems overly intense, particularly during trying times when multiple adverse events occur. It strains credulity to believe that leaders would disregard such glaring indicators.

Luna Lovegood’s Quirky Wisdom (Perfect Sense)

Luna’s unique allure and quiet resilience set her apart. Her genuine faith in intangible concepts and her comforting, sincere backing of Harry feel real and invigorating.

The film beautifully captures her as a distinctive friend, enhancing the group’s dynamics with her warm and profound influence.

The Battle in the Department of Mysteries (Zero Sense)

The battle inside the Department of Mysteries is exhilarating yet confusing. The design of this peculiar location, featuring rotating chambers and misplaced items, doesn’t follow a logical pattern.

What’s the reason for such careless storage of the prophecy? The quick tempo of the movie often omits explanations, resulting in a fragmented portrayal of the setting and the fight scenes.

The Power of Friendship and Resistance (Perfect Sense)

In this film, the emphasis on Harry, along with his companions, taking a united stand against Umbridge and Voldemort is perfectly executed. Their unwavering loyalty and courage propel the narrative forward.

As a devoted film enthusiast, I can’t help but marvel at the scenes reminiscent of the Room of Requirement training and the climactic battle, for it underscores the power of unity in the face of adversity. These moments serve as a potent reminder that standing together for what is right isn’t just idealistic; it’s a beacon of inspiration that guides us through even the toughest battles.

2025-08-08 14:32