5 Classic Monsters Jacob Elordi Could Play After FRANKENSTEIN

by

Guillermo del Toro’s new take on Frankenstein is generating a lot of buzz online, and not just for the gothic horror itself. While fans are excited for del Toro’s vision, actor Jacob Elordi, who plays the monster, is also a major draw. Elordi already had a dedicated following thanks to his intense and sensitive roles, and even his fashion choices. But Frankenstein seems to have amplified the attention, judging by the reactions on platforms like Letterboxd and TikTok. A captivating lead actor portraying a classic, misunderstood character is proving to be a big hit, especially with those who love a good monster story.

Eldori’s imposing size isn’t just for show; he’s a physically expressive actor, much like those who famously played classic monsters. Think of actors like Bela Lugosi, Christopher Lee, and Boris Karloff – they all built impressive careers by embodying these iconic, monstrous roles and utilizing their physical presence and range.

I’ve been thinking about a kind of actor we just don’t see enough of these days – Bill Skarsgård comes closest, I think, and it’s a real loss. It’s such a fantastic opportunity for an actor to really dig deep and explore everything about being human, both physically and emotionally. I immediately think of Peter Cushing in those classic Hammer horror films like Horror of Dracula and The Curse of Frankenstein – playing the monster in both! There was something so striking and graceful about how he moved and spoke. These roles might not get awards attention, but they’re the kinds of performances that truly make an actor unforgettable.

Could we see Jacob Elordi earning Oscar nominations with roles like this in the future? The Academy seems more open to horror and sci-fi now, and his recent monster performance is already generating excitement. Perhaps taking on similar characters could lead to even more success. He’s already set to play Heathcliff in an upcoming film adaptation of Wuthering Heights, and here are five more classic, slightly darker roles he might be perfect for.

Satan (Paradise Lost)

John Milton’s portrayal of Satan is like the first example of a brooding, rebellious character – the original ’emo antihero.’ He’s captivating and world-weary, and inspires the kind of protective, yet ultimately futile, feelings often seen in online fan communities. This connection isn’t accidental, as Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein – both the book and Guillermo del Toro’s movie – heavily draws inspiration from Paradise Lost. Jacob Elordi has already demonstrated his ability to play a character consumed by that same Miltonic sadness, making Satan a natural and compelling role for him.

In Frankenstein, Jacob Elordi portrays a deeply wounded and longing creature, one who desperately wants affection but expresses it through anger. His performance evokes a godlike being struggling with very human emotions, similar to Satan in Paradise Lost. Picture a towering Elordi, resembling the immense Satan described in the poem, standing on a vast battlefield and delivering the famous line, “Better to reign in Hell than serve in Heav’n,” with a single, poignant tear – it would likely become a viral sensation.

Erik/Phantom (The Phantom of the Opera) 

The character of the Phantom, as created by Gaston Leroux, demands an actor with both a powerful stage presence and the ability to convey deep emotion. Erik is a complex figure – a gifted composer, but also a killer and someone consumed by romantic obsession. He might be the most dramatically intense masked character ever written. Jacob Elordi seems perfectly suited to capture the character’s over-the-top emotionality while also portraying the underlying tragedy. Plus, there’s a compelling connection: Guillermo del Toro has expressed his desire to direct a new film adaptation of The Phantom of the Opera, which feels particularly fitting after his success with Frankenstein.

Jacob also has a surprisingly good singing voice, as hinted at in Priscilla. While he might not be a Broadway star just yet, he’s full of surprises and could be! He consistently shows new talents, so it wouldn’t be shocking if he has a truly beautiful voice, able to handle a challenging song like “Music of the Night.” His take on the Phantom could be a fresh, youthful, and intense one, and he could even bring the dark, obsessive energy of his Euphoria character, Nate, to create a compellingly scary and seductive performance.

Dorian Gray (The Picture of Dorian Gray) 

Jacob Elordi seems perfectly suited to play Dorian Gray. The character is a strikingly handsome man who never ages outwardly, but his inner self decays. Oscar Wilde’s Dorian is charming yet empty, troubled, and constantly teetering on the edge of a breakdown. What truly captivates about him isn’t just his good looks, but the disturbing contrast between his appearance and the horrifying reflection of his true nature in the portrait – the fear of confronting your darkest desires.

I’m really captivated by Jacob Elordi’s acting. He’s amazing at switching between seeming completely cold and then falling apart emotionally – it’s perfect for the roles he plays. Thinking about Nate, no one does ‘beautifully damaged’ quite like him. But it’s more than that; he brings this underlying sadness to his characters that makes me think they could be so much more than just spoiled or reckless – they could be genuinely heartbreaking.

Grendel (Beowulf)

Grendel is often seen as a terrifying monster, but he’s actually a deeply misunderstood character. He wasn’t cast out for being malicious; he was simply excluded and left out. Hearing the happiness of others, he desperately wants to belong, and his violent outbursts stem from feeling rejected and unwanted. It’s a surprisingly relatable story, isn’t it?

Traditionally, Grendel is seen as a monstrous, powerful creature. However, recent interpretations explore the sadness and pain behind his actions. Actor Jacob Elordi could perfectly capture this complexity, portraying Grendel not as a simple monster, but as a lonely, damaged figure whose anger stems from being an outcast. Imagine him emerging from the swamp, covered in vegetation and water, gazing wistfully at the celebrations within the mead hall – a place he’s forever excluded from. It’s a compelling and surprisingly attractive image.

Hyde (The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde) 

Hyde is a character defined by his sudden bursts of violence and unpredictable behavior, and actor Jacob Elordi has proven he can convincingly switch between being charming and threatening. What’s truly compelling about Hyde is his complex nature – he represents both the monstrous side of Dr. Jekyll and a reflection of the hidden parts of himself that society suppresses.

Jacob Elordi excels at portraying complex men who are struggling to hide their darker sides. He’d be perfect for a Victorian-era take on Jekyll and Hyde, bringing a real sense of tragedy and inner conflict to the role. It would be fascinating to see him play the contrast between a proper, reserved Jekyll and a wild, unrestrained Hyde, and his imposing height would make for some truly dramatic scenes.

Read More

2025-11-19 20:34