15 Darkest Marvel & DC Arcs They Tried to Bury

Many comic books strive to blend heroic deeds with difficult times, yet some narratives delve so profoundly into darkness that even Marvel and DC tend to keep them out of the limelight. These story arcs, filled with bleak themes, intense violence, or contentious decisions, sometimes overstep the boundaries of mainstream popularity, frequently slipping back into obscurity.

This compilation reveals 15 grim storylines from publishers that they attempted to minimize or hide. These narratives have left an indelible impact, though their intensity sometimes makes them difficult to fully appreciate due to their challenging nature.

15. Spider-Man: Reign (2006-2007)

In this story set in a bleak future, an older Peter Parker, who has hung up the Spider-Man suit, grapples with his life. The city is under strict government control, and the weight of past regrets, such as Mary Jane’s cancer-related death due to his radioactive encounter, heavily burdens him.

In my perspective, the somber imagery and motifs of remorse and deterioration in the Spider-Man narrative deviate significantly from the typically optimistic vibe. It’s seldom that Marvel revisits this storyline, perhaps because of the immense emotional heft it carries and the strong fan response against its darker interpretation.

14. The Death of Jean DeWolff (1985-1986)

In this Marvel saga, Spider-Man pursues the Sin-Eater, a ruthless assassin responsible for the death of police captain Jean DeWolff, who was a dear friend. The narrative delves into Peter’s growing anger and precarious hold on self-control, fueled by his symbiote costume.

In contrast to the usual lighter narratives associated with Spider-Man, this storyline dared to explore heavy themes like vengeance and moral conflict, which may not be commonly found in his tales. Marvel might choose to minimize its occurrence, possibly to keep Peter’s heroic persona unmarred by such intense anger.

13. Batman & Dracula: Red Rain (1991)

In the fascinating realm of DC’s Elseworlds, I found myself drawn to a thrilling narrative where Batman squares off against the enigmatic Dracula. The storyline takes an intriguing twist as it transforms Bruce Wayne into a vampire, a transformation that sets in motion a chilling spiral of bloodthirsty actions. As the line between hero and monster blurs, he finds himself taking lives of villains, while simultaneously putting a strain on his relationships with valued allies.

Fans found the brutal, horror-influenced storyline and Batman’s descent into inhumanity shocking. It’s possible that DC is keeping this trilogy under wraps because of its excessive violence and deviation from Batman’s traditional moral code.

12. The Punisher: The End (2004)

In this standalone Marvel story, we find Frank Castle surviving in a desolate world following a devastating nuclear conflict. Escaping from a shelter, he hunts down the final remnants of power-hungry rulers. However, his journey ends tragically amidst the ruins, leaving his purpose seemingly unfulfilled.

It’s challenging to market the gloomy atmosphere and absence of hope typically found in Punisher stories because they usually focus on action. Marvel probably doesn’t promote it much since its pessimistic viewpoint might not appeal to many readers.

11. Heroes in Crisis (2018-2019)

In this tale by DC, the focus is on a specialized sanctuary for superheroes dealing with mental health issues, amidst which gruesome murders take place. This unveils Wally West as an unintentional murderer. The narrative delves into the theme of trauma, but concludes with Wally being unfairly branded as a villain, causing an uproar among fans.

DC chose to keep a safe distance from the portrayal of sensitive mental health topics and the damaging depiction of Wally’s character, due to backlash from fans who cherished him as their favorite hero. This controversial storyline is seldom mentioned or revisited in subsequent works.

10. Marvel Zombies (2005-2006)

In this Marvel saga, a zombie outbreak transforms once-noble characters such as Spider-Man and the Hulk into cannibalistic creatures. These former heroes now feast on humans, even consuming friends and relatives in a grisly, twisted reality.

The act of one comic character consuming another and the diminishing valor left readers stunned. Marvel seems to be curbing its broad promotion efforts, possibly to maintain the dignity of their hero characters, although it was presented in ‘What If…?’

9. The Clone Saga (1994-1996)

In Marvel’s Spider-Man saga, a plotline emerges involving duplicates of character Peter Parker, among them Ben Reilly who is presented as the genuine Spider-Man. However, this is later exposed as a scheme by the Green Goblin, leading to uncertainty about Peter’s authenticity and mental state.

Marvel chose to minimize the complex storyline and Peter’s legacy due to fan criticism, as it is often overlooked in Spider-Man stories. This topic remains sensitive.

8. Green Lantern: Emerald Twilight (1994)

In this storyline for DC Comics, Hal Jordan, overwhelmed by the devastation of Coast City, loses his sanity and ends up murdering other Green Lanterns and stealing their power rings in a desperate attempt to revive his city. As a result, he transforms into the antagonist known as Parallax.

Fans were left dumbfounded when Hal Jordan’s unexpected transformation into a killer was revealed. Later on, DC Comics explained this twist as being due to possession, but the haunting undertones of the initial narrative have kept it from receiving much attention in Green Lantern lore.

7. What If…? Dark Phoenix (1989)

In Marvel’s ‘What If…?’ comic book, the storyline delves into a scenario where Jean Grey’s Dark Phoenix alter ego remains uncontrolled, resulting in her annihilating the X-Men and causing widespread destruction to the universe. The magnitude of this devastation is deeply unsettling.

Reading the story can be quite a weighty experience due to its profound sense of cosmic sadness and Jean’s heart-wrenching descent. Marvel may shy away from revisiting this tale to preserve Jean’s heroic image.

6. Kraven’s Last Hunt (1987)

In this Marvel storyline, Kraven the Hunter manages to capture and fake Spider-Man’s death, assuming the role to demonstrate his supremacy. Later, under the belief that he has triumphed, Kraven ends his own life.

In the world of Spider-Man comics, the themes of suicide and psychological intensity stood out significantly. Marvel Comics have generally been cautious when addressing these heavy topics because they contrast sharply with their traditional, kid-friendly persona, creating a stark contrast due to the darker tone.

5. The Dark Knight Returns (1986)

In this innovative retelling set in DC Comics, an aged Batman emerges from retirement in a grim, post-apocalyptic landscape, where he confronts a crooked establishment and a ruthless Superman. This narrative, marked by intense violence and complex moral dilemmas, significantly reshaped the character of Batman.

The grim, brooding atmosphere, where characters are complex anti-heroes rather than traditional heroes, was revolutionary yet polarizing. DC Comics approaches this style with careful consideration, as it often eclipses the brighter Batman narratives.

4. Injustice: Gods Among Us (2013-2016)

In this DC storyline linked to the video game, Superman is portrayed as transforming into a tyrant following the Joker’s deception, which leads him to believe he has killed Lois Lane and devastated Metropolis. He goes on to eliminate any heroes who dare defy him.

Fans were troubled by the unexpected transformation of Superman into a tyrant. It’s probably separated from the primary storyline by DC Comics to maintain Superman’s noble image and ideals.

3. Flashpoint (2011)

In an altered version of DC’s universe, The Flash unintentionally brings about a grim, post-apocalyptic landscape by rescuing his mother. Instead of the familiar vigilante we know, Batman is portrayed as a brutal Thomas Wayne, and heroes perish in a world ravaged by war.

In a similar vein, just as Superman’s imprisonment casts a gloomy shadow, so too does the world, with its heavy losses, have a grim aspect. However, unlike this, the DC universe tends not to linger on its darker aspects, often connecting it to their New 52 reboot.

2. Identity Crisis (2004-2005)

In this DC tale, the cold-blooded killing of Sue Dibny is concealed, unveiling disturbing truths about the heroes, such as instances of sexual misconduct. This somber narrative, filled with questionable morals, sent shockwaves throughout the DC Multiverse.

In response to the contentious management of traumatic events and negative reactions from fans, DC chose to minimize the focus on this issue. This storyline is often overlooked or not emphasized in current adaptations due to its controversial nature.

1. Marvel Ruins (1995)

In this alternate Marvel Universe scenario, things turn disastrously awry: Spider-Man succumbs to a fatal virus, Daredevil meets his end through radiation exposure, and superheroes experience unspeakable fates. This grim narrative paints a bleak, despairing picture of the Marvel world.

The persistent sadness and vividly depicted fatalities gave it a dismal tone that wasn’t appealing to a broad audience. Marvel scarcely mentions it because it contradicts their optimistic heroic ideology.

2025-07-06 15:15