10 Things From ‘The Umbrella Academy’ That Made Absolutely No Sense

I’ve become captivated by Netflix’s “The Umbrella Academy” due to its intriguing blend of superheroic siblings, time-twisting events, and a tense family dynamic. Inspired by Gerard Way’s Dark Horse comics, the series focuses on the Hargreeves siblings as they grapple with impending doom and internal struggles while living under the enigmatic guidance of their adoptive father, Reginald Hargreeves.

What continually draws me in is the unique, offbeat vibe of the show, yet there are instances that make me furrow my brow. From inconsistencies in the plot to decisions that seem bizarre, here’s a rundown of ten aspects within the series that don’t quite fit together logically.

10. The Mystery of Reginald’s Baby-Buying Spree

In a rather unusual turn of events, Reginald Hargreeves manages to take custody of seven children endowed with superpowers who were born to different women in 1989. Amazingly, no one seems to raise an eyebrow at this seemingly unlawful global adoption process given his wealth and eccentric nature. One may wonder, how does he accomplish this grand-scale action that appears to be akin to human trafficking without facing any legal repercussions?

In the third season, things grow more peculiar when it comes to the Sparrow Academy, as he takes in a new group of children. However, the series fails to provide an answer on how he locates their mothers or why it doesn’t raise red flags that a billionaire is amassing super-powered infants like valuable collectibles without any interference from authorities.

9. Viktor’s Hidden Powers

Despite witnessing Viktor exhibit his powers as children, the Hargreeves siblings grow up under the impression that he lacks any supernatural abilities. One might wonder how it is possible for everyone to simply overlook his potential for cataclysmic energy discharges.

It’s surprising, isn’t it, that no one in Reginald’s family ever questioned why he drugged Viktor to suppress his powers, even though this went on for years. You’d think at least one of the siblings would have wondered about the oddity of having a ‘normal’ brother amidst a superhero academy.

8. The Umbrella Academy’s Vigilante Free Pass

The children of Hargreeves function as a covert superhero squad, often instigating disorder and devastation in the public eye, yet remain immune to any legal repercussions or inquiries from law enforcement. In the first season, they’re associated with impending doom-like events, but no one seems interested in probing further?

In a universe brimming with extraordinary abilities, I find it challenging to believe that a gang of masked adolescents could unleash chaos without law enforcement or governing bodies intervening. Given their notoriety, they seem like prime candidates for close observation.

7. Robot Mom Grace’s Existence

Regarding Reginald’s decision, it’s intriguing that he constructs a robotic nanny named Grace to look after his adopted children. While the idea is clever, it seems unusual. One might wonder why he opted for an indestructible android over a human caregiver, given his previous experience employing nannies.

Despite the secluded nature of their upbringing, the siblings rarely pondered over having a robotic mother, a fact that might lead one to assume they’d find it unsettling or ask questions about why Reginald opted for a mechanical caregiver instead of a human one.

6. The Moon Explosion Cover-Up

In the first season, Reginald sends Luther to the moon, allegedly for the purpose of protecting Earth. However, it’s eventually disclosed that this lunar assignment was unnecessary, connected to a fabricated apocalypse scenario. So, one might wonder, how did Reginald become privy to this lunar event?

The program fails to explain why he conceals this secret from Luther, nor does it reveal his method of prediction. It seems that this significant plot twist is included merely to provide Luther with a tragic trajectory without offering a clear rationale behind it.

5. Time Travel Without Rules

The main feature of Character Five is his ability to travel through time, yet the guidelines for this power are unclear and often vague. He seems to move through different time periods without much clarification on how he manages this skill or why it occasionally doesn’t work as expected.

In seasons two and three, there are changes in the timeline and puzzling paradoxes, yet the rules governing time travel seem to be applied haphazardly. It’s perplexing as to how Five consistently manages to arrive at the correct period given that time travel appears to be so unpredictable.

4. The 43 Pregnant Women Phenomenon

The story begins in 1989 when an unexpected event occurred, as 43 women mysteriously went into labor, although they weren’t pregnant just a moment earlier. This intriguing concept raises questions about the cause behind it and why exactly 43 women were affected.

In simpler terms, the comics depict an alien wrestling bout causing seismic vibrations that reach Earth, adding a touch of silliness to the storyline. Conversely, the TV series keeps things mysterious, creating the impression that the event is just a convenient element in the narrative.

3. Harlan’s Overpowered Abilities

In the second season, Viktor unintentionally bestows powers upon a young boy named Harlan. As it turns out, Harlan plays a significant role in season three. His powers are incredibly potent, matching those of Viktor’s, but one might wonder, what is the mechanism behind this transfer?

In the series, we don’t delve into if other family members could inherit powers like Harlan or the reason behind his extraordinary abilities being particularly strong. This plot device serves as a means to heighten tension without providing a detailed explanation of the underlying rules.

2. The Sparrow Academy’s Sudden Appearance

As a die-hard fan, I can’t help but be intrigued by season three’s arrival of the Sparrow Academy – a formidable rival superhero squad, all nurtured by Reginald in an alternate reality. Yet, one question lingers: How on earth does he effortlessly gather and adopt an entirely new batch of super-powered youngsters so swiftly?

In simpler terms, the series seems to neglect explaining when these new children belong in the storyline and why they were chosen instead of the original seven by Reginald. It appears that this unexpected turn was added purely for dramatic effect without proper setup or preparation beforehand.

1. Reginald’s Alien Agenda

It’s unclear why Reginald, who is actually an alien with a universal reset plan, chose to take in and raise human children as future heroes, given that his ultimate objective involves a complete overhaul of the universe.

In seasons three and four, it’s suggested that he may be an alien, but the series fails to provide a clear explanation as to why he’s here on Earth or what his ultimate goal is. This major revelation raises more questions than it answers.

2025-07-22 10:44