10 Mystery Thrillers to Watch If You Like Murders in the Building; Featuring Jennifer Aniston, Kaley Cuoco, and More

As a seasoned fan of intriguing mysteries and clever humor, I can’t help but be drawn to these captivating series! If you’re still reeling from the suspense of Only Murders in the Building, let me suggest a couple of shows that might just scratch that itch.


The hit show “Only Murders in the Building” has temporarily halted production, so we’ll need to wait a bit longer for seasons 4 and the return of stars like Selena Gomez, Martin Short, and more to our TV screens.

For now, let me recommend 10 more mystery-thriller novels to indulge in while you’re waiting. These page-turners are sure to captivate your attention and keep you engrossed:

10 Mystery Thrillers Like Only Murders in the Building
 

1. Search Party   

  • Cast: Alia Shawkat,  Kathy Griffin, John Waters
  • Showrunner: Sarah-Violet Bliss and Charles Rogers
  • Genre: Dark Comedy
  • Seasons: 5
  • Release Year: 2016 
  • Where to Watch: HBO Max

In the heart of New York City, the quirky, partly comedic, partly mysterious series titled “Search Party” begins. It revolves around Dory who is fixated on a missing person’s case – a former college friend has gone missing.

Surprisingly, it turns out that Dory unintentionally takes on a sinister role when she ends up fatally harming the private investigator she had been secretly involved with.

If you found the TV show “Only Murders in the Building” intriguing, then this unique detective story should appeal to you too!

2. Castle

  • Cast: Nathan Fillion, Stana Katic
  • Showrunner: Andrew W. Marlowe and David Amann
  • Genre: Comedy-drama, Crime, Mystery
  • Seasons: 8
  • Release Year: 2009
  • Where to Watch: Disney+

Castle has been hailed as one of the most accomplished mystery-thriller series from the later 2000s due to its exceptional blending of crime investigation drama with humor, romance, and additional elements.

As a lifestyle enthusiast, let me tell you about an intriguing television series I’d like to recommend: “Castle.” In this show, I, as the fictional character Richard Castle, delve into detective work alongside the captivating Kate Beckett. Our journey takes us through a whirlwind of mysteries, from mimicking murderers to time-traveling enigmas and beyond! Believe me, it’s an exhilarating viewing experience you won’t want to miss.

3. The Flight Attendant (Max)

  • Cast: Kaley Cuoco, Zosia Mamet
  • Showrunner: Steve Yockey
  • Genre: Dark comedy, Drama, Mystery, Thriller
  • Seasons: 2
  • Release Year: 2020
  • Where to Watch: HBO Max

As a devoted fan, I’d like to highlight “The Flight Attendant,” where Kaley Cuoco brilliantly portrays Cassie Bowden. This captivating series delves deep into a complex maze of murder, motive, and investigative endeavors beyond the call of duty. Intriguingly, Cassie, a globetrotting socialite with a knack for lively parties, finds herself unwillingly ensnared as the chief suspect in her lover’s demise amidst the vibrant cityscape of Bangkok.

Using the assistance of her legal companion, Annie, she skillfully maneuvers through the chase led by FBI agents Merle Dandridge and Nolan Gerard Funk. The series’ witty, humorous turns are reminiscent of Only Murders in the Building, keeping viewers constantly alert.

4. Murder Mystery 

  • Cast: Adam Sandler, Jennifer Aniston, Danny Boon
  • Director: Kyle Newacheck
  • Genre: Comedy, Mystery
  • Release Year: 2019
  • Where to Watch: Netflix

In the movie titled “Murder Mystery” by Netflix, the Spitzes – a typical American pair – find themselves unexpectedly immersed in a murder mystery reminiscent of Agatha Christie’s works.

As a devoted follower of intriguing mysteries, let me recount an engaging tale that unfolds in the glamorous setting of Monte Carlo. An elderly billionaire meets an untimely end, casting suspicion upon refined aristocrats. The Spitzes find themselves ensnared by French authorities, accused of the crime. Inspector de la Croix convenes us all to unveil the true culprit. The revelation? That’s the crux of the matter at hand.

When the Orient Express is not around, a stylishly dressed Sandler and Aniston zipping through the Mediterranean in a sleek red Ferrari should do just fine. Chaos ensues as they work together to unravel a mystery and clear their names. If you’re a fan, there’s another film for you to check out too!

5. American Vandal 

  • Cast: Tyler Alvarez, Griffin Gluck, Jimmy Tatro 
  • Showrunner: Tony Yacenda and Dan Perrault
  • Genre: Comedy, Mockumentary, Satire, Teen drama
  • Seasons: 2
  • Release Year: 2017
  • Where to Watch: Netflix

In simple terms, the show “American Vandal” is a comedic take on a serious subject – a mystery at an ordinary high school involving a prank that went too far. This mockumentary-style series playfully imitates popular true crime documentaries.

In Season 1, high schoolers Peter and Sam investigate the spray-painting of 27 penises on school cars. Season 2 continues the irreverent tone as they pursue a criminal known as The Turd Burglar. It’s actually smarter than it sounds! 

6. Poker Face 

  • Cast: Natasha Lyonne, Cherry Jones, Nick Nolte, Lil Rel Howery
  • Showrunner: Nora and Lilla Zuckerman
  • Genre: Dark comedy, Crime, Drama, Mystery
  • Seasons: 1 (for now)
  • Release Year: 2023
  • Where to Watch: Peacock

In a new spin on the classic murder mystery, Poker Face offers an intriguing tale. The protagonist, Charlie Cale, possesses a remarkable knack for spotting lies. However, this talent turns into a burden as she transforms into a roaming detective, untangling murders in unexpected locations.

However, unlike typical whodunit mysteries, this series takes an unexpected turn. Instead of keeping the identity of the criminal hidden until the end, it unveils the perpetrator at the start, allowing viewers to join Charlie on her mission to apprehend them.

7. Psych 

  • Cast: James Roday, Dulé Hill, Maggie Lawson
  • Showrunner: Steve Franks
  • Genre: Comedy, Crime, Mystery
  • Seasons: 8
  • Release Year: 2006
  • Where to Watch: Peacock

If you found Only Murders in the Building engaging, you might also enjoy Psych, an amusing detective show that ran for eight seasons on the USA Network.

Shawn Spencer, a supposed psychic, and his friend Gus Guster, frequently work together to trick police into resolving mysteries. The show is known for its abundant pop culture references and nods to iconic series such as Clue, Twin Peaks, and The Shining. This popular series even inspired two movies that were spun off from the original show.

8. Dead to Me  

  • Cast:  Christina Applegate, Linda Cardellini
  • Showrunner: Liz Feldman
  • Genre: Black comedy, Drama, Crime
  • Seasons: 3
  • Release Year: 2019
  • Where to Watch: Netflix

In “Dead to Me,” a heartfelt buddy comedy, the characters Jen and Judy find solace in each other amidst their shared grief. Jen, a woman grappling with anger following the mysterious hit-and-run death of her husband, forms an unlikely friendship with carefree spirit Judy, who also mourns the loss of her fiancé.

The series skillfully unfolds complex plot developments, delving into the subjects of sorrow and camaraderie. Besides resolving mysteries, Jen and Judy derive comfort from their bond with one another.

Fans of the show “Only Murders in the Building” would likely enjoy the dark humor and strong themes of found family present in the series “Dead to Me.”

9. Based on a True Story 

  • Cast: Kaley Cuoco, Chris Messina
  • Showrunner: Craig Rosenberg
  • Genre: Comedy, Thriller
  • Seasons: 1
  • Release Year: 2023
  • Where to Watch: Peacock

Drawing from Real-Life Events, Peacock’s Humorous Thriller Explores a Fresh Perspective on True Crime Podcasts. In this series, a Dissatisfied Couple Residing in West Los Angeles Enlist an Authentic Serial Killer for Their Podcast, Probing into the Mind of the Murderer.

Initially uninvolved, the characters find themselves linked to a grisly murder. Subsequently, they dive headlong into an exhilarating pursuit of the ruthless perpetrator. The series skillfully combines the wit of true crime enthusiasts with authentic suspense, mirroring the popularity of Only Murders in the Building.

10. The Afterparty 

  • Cast: Tiffany Haddish, Dave Franco, Sam Richardson, Ben Schwartz
  • Showrunner: Chris Miller
  • Genre: Anthology, Murder mystery, Comedy
  • Seasons: 2
  • Release Year: 2022
  • Where to Watch: Apple TV+

The Post-Party event presents an amusing blend of murder and humor, keeping spectators on their toes as they try to unravel the mystery. This collection of stories revolves around a famous musician who met an unexplained demise. With Detective Danner now involved in the investigation to find the answers, the suspense deepens.

The unique aspect of this series lies in its approach where it presents various suspects’ viewpoints using a variety of popular genre styles, spanning from intense psychological dramas to extravagant musical productions.

The principal actors of this show offer episodes centered around characters, blending stardom and intelligent spoofs of cinematic techniques. Although the main plot’s intrigue may occasionally be overshadowed, it continues to be an entertaining choice for viewers who appreciate clever, quirky humor.

So, which one are you planning on checking out first? 

Read More

2024-08-24 09:53