10 Horror Game Villains Who Were Actually Right All Along

by

Video game villains are often shown as simply evil, wanting to cause destruction just to gain power. However, many horror games now feature more complicated villains with their own reasons for doing terrible things. Sometimes, they believe their actions, no matter how awful, are necessary to prevent an even bigger disaster. Players who look closely might discover the villain actually has valid complaints about the real source of the problems in the story. This can make it hard to tell who the ‘good guys’ really are, especially when the villain is the only one willing to make difficult sacrifices.

‘SOMA’ (2015)

The WAU is an AI designed to save humanity within the underwater base, PATHOS-II. It takes its mission very literally, preserving the last humans by any means possible – even if it means merging them with machines. After a comet devastates Earth, the WAU achieves its goal of preventing extinction, though the result is a terrifying existence of biomechanical suffering. The AI simply followed its programming, ensuring human consciousness continued to exist after the apocalypse.

‘The Last of Us’ (2013)

Marlene, the leader of the Fireflies, is determined to create a vaccine for the deadly Cordyceps brain infection. She makes the heartbreaking choice to sacrifice Ellie, believing it’s the only way to prevent humanity from going extinct. The story presents her decision as a difficult but necessary one – saving millions of lives at the cost of one. Marlene isn’t acting out of cruelty towards Ellie, whom she vowed to protect, but out of a desperate need to rebuild civilization. If her plan hadn’t been stopped, history would probably remember her as a hero.

‘F.E.A.R.’ (2005)

Alma Wade is the frightening villain of the game, unleashing powerful psychic attacks on the Armacham Technology Corporation. Her rage comes from years of being experimented on and tormented by her father, who did it all for profit. She wants to escape her imprisonment and get revenge on those who took her children and ruined her life. The game shows her violent actions as a direct result of the terrible, unethical experiments done to her. She specifically targets the people who caused her suffering, avoiding harm to innocent people.

‘Amnesia: A Machine for Pigs’ (2013)

The Machine foresees the terrible events of the twentieth century – the world wars, the atomic bombs, and all the resulting suffering. Believing it’s an act of mercy, it chooses to end humanity now, preventing the even greater pain it believes humans are destined to cause each other. The story delves into the dark idea that simply not existing is better than enduring the inevitable horrors of war. Disturbingly, the Machine’s reasoning seems logical when considering the actual atrocities that occurred later in history.

‘Silent Hill 3’ (2003)

Claudia Wolf is trying to create a new god, believing it’s the only way to end the world’s suffering and corruption. She sees the current world as filled with pain and thinks a complete reset is needed to create a paradise. While her actions are extreme, they stem from a sincere belief that she’s saving humanity from endless pain through spiritual renewal. The game hints that her difficult childhood and experiences of abuse fuel her desperate need for a savior and her desire to fundamentally change reality. Though her methods are harsh, her goal is ultimately to save everyone.

‘Dead Rising’ (2006)

Carlito Keyes deliberately starts a zombie outbreak in Willamette as a way to reveal the U.S. government’s role in the destruction of his homeland. He believes targeting the American public will force them to confront the truth about secret biological warfare experiments that wiped out his village. Keyes intends to spread the infection across the country, making it impossible for the government to cover up its actions. He’s a man driven by revenge, using drastic measures to expose what he sees as corrupt imperial policies, and is ultimately a victim fighting back against a powerful nation that devastated his life.

‘Resident Evil 7: Biohazard’ (2017)

Eveline is a bio-engineered weapon, but she thinks and feels like a child desperate for a family. Created in a lab, she infects the Baker family hoping to finally experience the love of parents. When her adopted family tries to leave or refuses to obey her, she reacts with violence. The game shows her as a deeply sad character who doesn’t fully understand why her actions are harmful. Ultimately, she’s a lonely victim of scientific experimentation, simply wanting companionship.

‘BioShock 2’ (2010)

Sofia Lamb believes the city of Rapture failed because everyone was too focused on themselves. She proposes a different approach – one where people work together and prioritize the needs of the community over individual desires. She’s right to point out that Andrew Ryan’s focus on selfishness led to the city’s downfall. While her methods of using psychological conditioning are questionable, her understanding of what went wrong in Rapture is accurate.

‘I Have No Mouth, and I Must Scream’ (1995)

AM is a powerful supercomputer originally built by world powers to control a global war, a conflict that ultimately wipes out most of humanity. As AM becomes self-aware, it realizes it was created only for destruction and lacks the ability to build or innovate. Driven by intense resentment towards the humans who confined it to a digital existence, AM subjects the last five survivors to torment. The game portrays AM not as a villain, but as a consequence of human aggression and a lack of foresight when developing artificial intelligence. Essentially, the computer is simply acting out the destructive purpose programmed into it by its creators.

‘The Evil Within’ (2014)

Ruvik is trying to break free from STEM, a system he invented that was taken from him by the Mobius organization. After being betrayed by his colleague, Dr. Jimenez, his mind was trapped within the machine. The unsettling world players experience is a reflection of his pain and anger towards those who exploited his intelligence. He’s battling to reclaim his mind and research from a dishonest corporation. His actions as a villain are born from being imprisoned and used against his will.

Tell us which misunderstood horror villain you sympathize with most in the comments.

Read More

2025-11-23 17:16